mixsoon vs. EltaMD: The Ultimate Sunscreen Showdown for Your Face
Choosing the right daily sunscreen is one of the most important steps in any skincare routine, but it can also be the most frustrating. With so many options promising no white cast and a perfect finish, how do you pick the one that’s truly right for you? This comparison is for shoppers who are tired of greasy, chalky, or pore-clogging formulas and are looking for a reliable, cosmetically elegant sunscreen that they’ll actually want to wear every day.
We’re putting four highly-rated contenders head-to-head: the viral Korean beauty favorite mixsoon Bean Sunscreen, the dermatologist-beloved EltaMD UV Clear (in both tinted and untinted versions), and a specialized formula for melanin-rich skin. We’ll break down the key decision-making factors, including texture, finish, suitability for sensitive skin, and overall value, to help you find your perfect match.
Quick Comparison at a Glance
| Product | Rating (/5) | Key Feature | Best For | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| mixsoon Bean Sunscreen 1.69 Fl. Oz. / 50ml SPF 50 Airy Texture Type Lightweight No White Cast For Face Korean Glass Skin Care | ~4.5/5 | Lightweight, Airy Texture | Glass Skin Enthusiasts | No white cast, dewy finish | Small bottle, may be shiny for some |
| EltaMD UV Clear Face Sunscreen SPF 46, Oil-Free Sunscreen with Zinc Oxide, Dermatologist Recommended | ~4.7/5 | Niacinamide & Zinc Formula | Sensitive & Acne-Prone Skin | Calming, oil-free, great under makeup | Can leave a slight white cast on deeper skin |
| EltaMD UV Clear Tinted Face Sunscreen, SPF 46 Oil- Free with Zinc Oxide, Dermatologist Recommended | ~4.6/5 | Light Tint for Coverage | Light to Medium Skin Tones | Minimizes white cast, evens skin tone | Tint may not match all skin tones |
| Face & Body Moisturizing Sunscreen Lotion SPF 30, No White-Residue for Melanin Rich Skin (2 Fl. Oz.) | ~4.3/5 | Formulated for Rich Melanin | Deep Skin Tones | Truly no white residue, moisturizing | Lower SPF, not specifically for face |
In-Depth Product Reviews
mixsoon Bean Sunscreen SPF 50
Users are head over heels for this K-beauty gem’s texture, consistently describing it as incredibly lightweight, airy, and fast-absorbing. It melts into the skin without any greasy residue, leaving behind a coveted dewy, “glass skin” finish that looks hydrated and plump. Many reviewers note it works beautifully as a primer under makeup, providing a smooth canvas without pilling.
The most common complaint is the small bottle size; you’ll go through it quickly with daily use. A few users with very oily skin found the dewy finish crossed over into looking too shiny for their preference and required powder to mattify.
Ideal Candidate: This is the perfect pick for dry, combination, or normal skin types chasing that hydrating, dewy Korean glow, and for anyone who has struggled with white casts from mineral formulas.
- No White Cast & Strong UV Protection : Mixsoon Bean Sunscreen offers SPF50 for powerful UV protection, effectively preve…
- Silky Application : This sunscreen features a lightweight, silky texture that spreads smoothly, making it the perfect ch…
- Safe and Gentle Ingredients : Made with natural ingredients like wheat sprout extract and fermented bean, it is suitable…
EltaMD UV Clear Facial Sunscreen SPF 46 (Untinted)
This is a cult-favorite for a reason. Users with sensitive, rosacea-prone, and acneic skin swear by its calming properties. They love that it feels weightless, layers perfectly under makeup, and provides serious protection without causing breakouts or irritation. The inclusion of niacinamide is a huge plus for many, as it helps to soothe redness and improve skin texture over time.
The primary drawback mentioned is that it can leave a minimal white cast, particularly on medium to deep skin tones. While it’s far less than traditional zinc sunscreens, it’s not completely invisible on everyone.
Ideal Candidate: This is the holy grail for those with sensitive, acne-prone, or reactive skin who need a reliable, non-comedogenic formula that offers both protection and skincare benefits.
EltaMD UV Clear Tinted Facial Sunscreen SPF 46
Reviewers who found the untinted version too pale adore this tinted alternative. The universal tint does an excellent job of neutralizing any white cast from the zinc oxide, providing a light, natural-looking coverage that evens out redness and minor imperfections. It boasts the same beloved, lightweight, and non-irritating formula as the original, making it a fantastic multitasker.
The main criticism is that the “universal” tint has a limited range. It works well for light to medium skin tones but can appear too ashy or orange on very fair or deep complexions.
Ideal Candidate: Best for individuals with light to medium skin tones who want the benefits of the EltaMD UV Clear formula with the added perk of light coverage to skip foundation.
Face & Body Moisturizing Sunscreen Lotion SPF 30 for Melanin Rich Skin
This product receives high praise for delivering on its number one promise: absolutely no white residue. Users with deep skin tones celebrate finally finding a sunscreen that blends in seamlessly without ashy-grey undertones. Its moisturizing formula is also a big win for those with dry skin, as it prevents the tight, chalky feeling some sunscreens cause.
The trade-off is the SPF 30 rating, which is lower than the other options here. Some users also note that while it works on the face, its richer consistency feels more like a body lotion and might be too heavy for those with oily or combination facial skin.
Ideal Candidate: This is a dedicated solution for people with deeper skin tones who prioritize a truly invisible finish and need a moisturizing, body-inclusive formula, and are comfortable with SPF 30 protection.
- Tailored for Melanin Rich Skin: Specially formulated for dark skin tones, our SPF 30 sunscreen lotion offers robust prot…
- Dual-Action Moisturizing: Acting as both a sunscreen and a moisturizer, our lotion is infused with nourishing natural in…
- Sheer, Residue-Free Application: Enjoy a sunscreen that leaves no white-cast or residue behind. Our sheer formula ensure…
How to Choose: The Buyer’s Guide
- What is your primary skin concern? If it’s acne or sensitivity, EltaMD UV Clear is your top choice. If it’s achieving a dewy glow, mixsoon wins. For eliminating white cast on deep skin, the specialized lotion is key.
- What finish do you prefer? Do you want a natural, velvety matte finish (EltaMD) or a hydrating, dewy glow (mixsoon)? Your answer will immediately narrow the field.
- Will you wear it under makeup? All of these are praised for playing well with makeup, but the lightweight, airy textures of mixsoon and EltaMD are particularly renowned for it.
- What is your skin tone? If you have a light to medium tone, the EltaMD Tinted is a great option. For deeper tones, the untinted EltaMD may leave a cast, making the specialized lotion or mixsoon better bets.
The Final Verdict
For those in a hurry: If you have sensitive or acne-prone skin, choose EltaMD UV Clear. If you have a deeper skin tone and want a guaranteed no-white-cast glow, mixsoon Bean Sunscreen is your winner. Always prioritize a formula you love the feel of, as that’s the one you’ll actually use every single day.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.